Avoiding independent contractor liability in M&A

2 weeks ago

Old Toronto, Ontario, Canada Deal Law Wire Full time

The distinction between employees and independent contractors is significant as it pertains to workers' legal entitlements. Employees have an exclusive working relationship with an employer, which engages rights and obligations under applicable employment legislation and the common law. By contrast, independent contractor agreements are entered into by legal and contractual equals. As a result, independent contractors are not afforded employment law protections.

The misclassification of employees as independent contractors continues to attract considerable legal action and media attention . Recently, Ontario has seen a rise in class action lawsuits involving claimants alleging to have been misclassified by their purported employers. If found to have misclassified employees, these companies could face claims for unpaid Employment Insurance and Canada Pension Plan contributions, wages and benefits, as well as various categories of damages. Canadian companies would be well served to consider the risk of inheriting independent contractor liability through M&A deals. Specifically, an assessment of the target company's workforce should be undertaken as part of the due diligence process to ensure that workers are classified correctly and penalties are avoided. An overview of the law relating to the classification of workers should help guide this analysis.

In a recent decision emerging from Quebec, an individual was held to be an employee despite being labelled an independent contractor in a franchise agreement with the deemed employer. In reaching this decision, the Supreme Court of Canada affirmed that the language used in an agreement is not determinative of whether an employment relationship exists between parties. According to the majority of the Court, "the inquiry must assess the actual nature of the relationship between the parties, regardless of the terms of and labels used in the franchise agreement." An employment relationship was identified based on several factors including the assumption of risk and opportunity of profit, degree of control and ownership of tools. Similar factors have been considered by courts in common law jurisdictions.

Notably, the Ontario Court of Appeal has recognized dependant contractors as an intermediate classification between an employee and independent contractor. Dependant contractors appear to work for themselves, but may be entitled to protections usually reserved for employees because of their dependence on a single employer. While this status is still developing, dependant contractors have been extended common law damages for wrongful dismissal.

Based on the foregoing, M&A due diligence must involve more than simply reviewing the independent contractor agreements of a target company. Whenever possible, buyers should also request access to employment data, contractor lists, job profiles, descriptions of services, service histories, pay records and other available information as part of the discovery process. Buyers should be attuned to the labour and employment practices of the companies they are dealing with in order to avoid independent contractor liability, particularly as this area of the law continues to unfold.

The author would like to thank Lila Yaacoub, summer student, for her assistance in preparing this legal update.

Stay informed on M&A developments andsubscribe to our blog today.

#J-18808-Ljbffr

  • Independent Contractor

    2 weeks ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada Guardium Security Services Ltd Full time

    Independent Contractor - Various SkillsWe here at Guardium are looking for Contractors in various trades to assist us in our rapidly growing renovations division. You will be responsible for demonstrating knowledge and skills relating to your trade, and upholding a professional demeanor and attitude in the workplace. Contractors will be responsible for...

  • Transactional Liability Underwriter

    2 weeks ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance Full time

    Who are we?A strategic and trusted insurance partner, Berkshire Hathaway Specialty Insurance (BHSI), provides a broad range of commercial property, casualty and specialty insurance coverages and outstanding service to customers and brokers around the world. Part of Berkshire Hathaway's insurance operations, we bring our solutions to market with our stellar...

  • Broker – Management Liability – FINEX

    2 weeks ago

    Old Toronto, Ontario, Canada Purves Redmond Limited Full time

    Purves Redmond Limited (PRL) is recognized as one of the leading independent insurance advisory and brokerage firms in Canada. Established in 1959, PRL has grown exponentially to represent and service clients globally. With five offices in Canada (Toronto, Vancouver, Calgary, Montreal, and Sudbury), PRL is a mid-sized brokerage firm with highly experienced...

  • Home Improvement Contractor for Residential and

    2 weeks ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada Handyman Connection of Etobicoke, ON Full time

    To meet the demands of our rapidly growing base of satisfied customers, Handyman Connection of Toronto West is seeking an experienced independent Contractor. This skilled craftsman would ideally have a variety of home improvement skills to support the growth of our business. Enjoys working in an individual setting. Handyman Connection is a locally owned and...

  • Independent Psychologist

    2 weeks ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada Layla Care Inc. Full time

    Independent Psychologist - Diagnostic Assessments We are seeking licensed clinical psychologists in Ontario to provide diagnostic assessments as independent contractors. Layla works with psychologists in private practice in Ontario, Alberta, British Columbia and Nova Scotia. We help complement your private practice with clients that align to your strengths...

  • Liability Claims Adjuster

    5 days ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Ontario, Canada Helmsman Management Services LLC Full time

    Company Description:Helmsman Management Services Canada Inc. is a wholly owned subsidiary of Helmsman Management Services LLC, a US-based third-party administrator (TPA) backed by the strength of Liberty Mutual Insurance, a Fortune 100 company. We have the flexibility of a TPA as we manage auto and general liability claims to the best possible outcome. With...

  • MT3 Independent Contract Lawyer

    2 weeks ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada MT>3, a Division of McCarthy Tétrault LLP Full time

    Join the roster at MT>3 a division of McCarthy Tétrault LLP and be part of a team using cutting edge technology to support the firm's legal teams. MT>3 is seeking Independent contract lawyers to work on a variety of interesting client matters. Our independent contract lawyers can be based in any location within Canada. QualificationsBachelor of Laws or...

  • EHS Advisor- Mechanical and Electrical Contractor

    2 weeks ago

    Old Toronto, Ontario, Canada JobContax Full time

    Job DescriptionOur client is one of leading Ireland's leading Mechanical, Electrical & Maintenance Contracting Companies currently embarking on an exciting phase of expansion throughout Ireland & Overseas. They service clients across a wide range of business sectors such as Pharmaceutical, Data Centres, Healthcare, and large Commercial Projects. They are...

  • Liability Claims Examiner

    2 weeks ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada RioCan Full time

    SummaryWho We AreRioCan is one of Canada's largest Real Estate Investment Trusts (REIT). We own, manage and develop retail-focused, increasingly mixed-use properties in Canada's major markets. We pioneered the REIT concept almost 30 years ago and have transformed Canadian real estate.We are proud to be recognized as one of Canada's Greenest Employers and a...

  • hse

    2 weeks ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada H&M Full time

    About the Role: As the Health & Safety Responsible for the CA Sales Market, in the Security function, you will help ensure a secure and compliant work environment. The incumbent will implement and oversee the national health and safety strategy, maintaining up-to-date policies, and ensuring adherence to local regulations. The candidate will enthusiastically...

  • Visual Fashion Merchandiser

    2 weeks ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada H&M Full time

    Company DescriptionHere's what's possible for H&M VISUAL MERCHANDISERS:Yes, we are seeking Visual Merchandisers, but only those who refuse to settle. Those who are fearless of pressure. You see, Visual Merchandisers here do more than just style our fashion according to the H&M guidelines; they also work with the Store Manager and Management team to maximize...

  • Compensation Specialist

    2 weeks ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada H&M Full time

    Company DescriptionAt H&M We believe that it's when you mix and match different talents, experiences, and styles that the real magic happens. That's why our teams are built with different personalities, talents and people from all kinds of backgrounds. If you are willing to learn, grow and help our customers and your colleagues, H&M will always be a place...

  • Remote and Hybrid Independent Contractor Technology Lawyers

    2 weeks ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada MT>Align, a division of McCarthy Tétrault LLP Full time

    About MT>AlignHave control over your hours. Work for yourself, but with usMT>Align, a division of McCarthy Tétrault LLP, pairs high caliber independent contract lawyers with our clients who need legal support. Through MT>Align, successful applicants will join our roster and will have the opportunity to potentially work on engagements providing sophisticated...

  • AVP, Liability Technical Underwriting

    1 month ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada Zurich Insurance Company Ltd. Full time

    The Opportunity Are you looking for a caring, collaborative, values-driven workplace with inspiring teammates and leaders? Do you have the ambition and desire to be the best and thrive at the most impactful global insurance provider in the world? Look no further than Zurich Canada. If you have experience in technical underwriting and are looking for a new...

  • AVP, Liability Technical Underwriting

    4 weeks ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada Zurich Insurance Company Ltd. Full time

    The Opportunity Are you looking for a caring, collaborative, values-driven workplace with inspiring teammates and leaders? Do you have the ambition and desire to be the best and thrive at the most impactful global insurance provider in the world? Look no further than Zurich Canada. If you have experience in technical underwriting and are looking for a new...

  • EMG Independent 1099

    2 weeks ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada Concentra Full time

    Overview Concentra, one of the largest health care companies in the nation, is looking for a Physiatrist / Neurologist to come on site to our location as a 1099 independent contractor to perform EMGs and NCS. This role is a contract position and is meant to compliment your current practice. A typical partnership will involve treating patients on site at...

  • Remote/Hybrid Independent Contractor Corporate Commercial Lawyer

    2 weeks ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada MT>Align, a division of McCarthy Tétrault LLP Full time

    About MT>AlignHave control over your hours. Work for yourself, but with usMT>Align, a division of McCarthy Tétrault LLP, pairs high calibre independent contract lawyers with our clients who need legal support. Through MT>Align, successful applicants will join our roster and will have the opportunity to potentially work on engagements providing sophisticated...

  • Model Governance and Operations Director

    2 weeks ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada M&T Bank Corporation Full time

    Model Governance and Operations Director page is loaded Model Governance and Operations Director Apply remote type Remote Eligible, Canada locations Remote, Canada time type Full time posted on Posted 3 Days Ago job requisition id R63381 Overview: Responsible for management and oversight of model risk governance and operation teams to create, manage and...

  • Experienced Independent Hairstylist

    2 weeks ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada Hair Collective Full time

    Hair Collective is EXPANDINGWe are Seeking an Independent Stylist that is passionate, driven and is qualified with new Haircut and Styling trends and all the latest techniques with balayage, foilayage, Teaseylight's, Babylights ect. Our salon uses Redken Fusion as our main colour line and Redken shades eq gloss and some Schwarzkopf Vibrance.*We are hiring...

  • Senior Claims Specialist, Liability

    6 days ago

    Toronto, Ontario, Canada Zurich Insurance Company Ltd. Full time

    The Opportunity Are you looking for a caring, collaborative, values-driven workplace with inspiring teammates and leaders? Do you have the ambition and desire to be the best and thrive at the most impactful global insurance provider in the world? Look no further than Zurich Canada. If you have experience handling commercial liability claims and are looking...